Showing posts with label IDES. Show all posts
Showing posts with label IDES. Show all posts

Monday, November 30, 2015

Illinois Accountants Need to React to Stern Warnings from the IDES Regarding Future Fraud Penalties for Independent Contractor Misclassification

December, 2015



Illinois accountants should be acutely aware that one of the newest audit strategies of the increasingly aggressive Illinois Department of Employment Security (IDES) is to give Illinois companies (who are currently being audited) stern warnings of hefty fraud penalties that these companies may face in the future!

HEFTY FRAUD PENALTIES: The standard routine that IDES auditors follow is to unleash the topic of future 60% fraud penalties at the “exit interview.” 

The exit interview is the final communication that the IDES auditor has with the company being audited. The IDES auditor solemnly informs  the company (or its representative) that if the company persists in wrongly classifying these workers as independent contractors (because the company now presumably knows, due to the current IDES audit, what it must change in terms of classifying workers as independent contractors ), then the company faces a bleak future of possible massive fraud penalties (and possible personal liability) for its alleged INTENTIONAL WRONGDOING!

AGGRESSIVE FOLLOW-UP AUDITS: To make matters even more dangerous, IDES audit supervisors have very recently started assigning FOLLOW-UP AUDITS in great numbers! Hitting previously audited companies with follow-up audits is a brand new and worrying audit strategy by the IDES!

So, if you have a client who has been audited before by the IDES (and whose independent contractors were reclassified to employee status by the IDES auditor!), that client may well be selected now for a FOLLOW-UP AUDIT!

Illinois companies who face a FOLLOW-UP AUDIT should brace themselves for Determination and Assessments (audit tax bills) with 24% interest – and then ANOTHER 60% fraud penalty on top of that – if they are found to have intentionally MISCLASSIFIED their independent contractors.  

Explain to your clients that 60% fraud penalties are the devastating weapon that IDES auditors will unleash at these FOLLOW-UP AUDITS.

In view of the combination of 1) potential fraud penalties of 60% and 2) follow-up IDES audits of Illinois companies who have had prior misclassification difficulties with IDES auditors and hearing officers, it is very important to restructure and make strategic changes to the Independent Contractor relationship. 

Please contact me so that we can evaluate your clients’ current independent contractor usage and risks and also discuss ideas for damage control in the event the IDES contacts your clients for follow up audits.

My office number is 630-377-1554. My cell number is 630-440-1945. My email address is najoerg@wesselssherman.com. I look forward to hearing from you sometime soon.

FREE COPY OF REGULATIONS PERTAINING TO SECTION 1402 FRAUD PENALTY: Also, if any readers of this article want a copy of the Illinois Unemployment Insurance Act as it relates to fraud penalties (Section 1402) or wishes a free copy of the Regulations pertaining to the fraud penalty law, please contact my legal assistant Tammy Nelson (tanelson@wesselssherman.com or 630-377-1554). I will continue to keep accountants updated as more becomes known about the new and developing situation concerning fraud penalties and IDES audits in general. 

Now is the time to act to protect Illinois clients who use independent contractors. 

Friday, March 13, 2015

The Difficult Job of Proving Misconduct to the Illinois Department of Employment Security (IDES) When a Truck Driver is Terminated for Poor Performance

March 2015
By Nancy E. Joerg, Esq.



As one would expect, sometimes a trucking company finds it best to terminate a truck driver for poor performance. This poor performance may involve very serious accidents or negligence (such as cross-dropping no lead gasoline into a premium tank, thereby contaminating that product). Sometimes, instead of properly loading thousands of gallons of no-lead and thousands of gallons of mid-grade, the driver carelessly loads thousands of gallons of no-lead and thousands of gallons of premium.

While there is of course usually no problem in terminating a driver who has had many accidents which cost the company time, money and damage to their reputation, our trucking clients are often surprised when they don’t win with the Illinois Department of Employment Security (IDES) - if the terminated truck driver files for unemployment insurance benefits with the IDES.

What many trucking clients don’t realize is that the IDES WILL give unemployment insurance benefits to drivers (even when they have had many serious accidents in the course of their employment) if the trucking company cannot successfully prove that these accidents were willful and deliberate on the part of the employee truck driver.

IDES DEFINITION OF MISCONDUCT: The IDES works under a strict legal definition of misconduct which requires that the trucking company prove that the incident was intentional, willful and deliberate. Mere negligence and terrible driving or a series of significant mistakes or accidents do not qualify as misconduct under the IDES definition.

Under Section 602A of the Illinois Unemployment Insurance Act, the definition of misconduct is:  “the deliberate and willful violation of a reasonable rule or policy of the employing unit, governing the individual’s behavior in performance of his work, provided such violation has harmed the employing unit or other employees or has been repeated by the individual despite a warning or other explicit instruction from the employing unit.” 

Section 602A requires deliberate and willful behavior and that behavior must have caused harm to the trucking company.  (These elements need to be proven by the trucking company in order for unemployment insurance benefits to be blocked.)

TIPS FOR TERMINATION LETTER: When you terminate a truck driver for a series of incidents in the course of their truck driving, indicate in the termination letter what reasonable rule or policy the truck driver intentionally failed to follow. This is a way to win with the IDES, by emphasizing the deliberate and willful nature of the driver’s behavior. For example, if the driver failed to double check the gasoline in a manner in which he was instructed by the trucking company, then that might be a winning strategy to block his claim for unemployment insurance benefits.

PROTESTING THE DRIVER’S CLAIM FOR UNEMPLOYMENT: Keep this in mind the next time you protest a truck driver’s claim for unemployment insurance benefits with the IDES…your goal is to prove to the IDES that the truck driver’s behavior was willful, deliberate and intentional. Merely pointing out what a bad driver that individual was is NOT a winning strategy. Accidents and negligence are (sadly) not enough.

For assistance with IDES audits, hearings, and independent contractor agreements (or for consultations on limiting your liability in the use of independent contractors), contact Attorney Nancy E. Joerg, who enjoys a nationwide reputation in working with companies who use Independent Contractors of all types. Nancy Joerg can be reached at Wessels Sherman's St. Charles, Illinois office: 630-377-1554 or email her at najoerg@wesselssherman.com.

Friday, February 27, 2015

Employer Alert: Keep Track of 30 Working Days for Illinois Unemployment Insurances Purposes

March 2010
By: Nancy E. Joerg, Esq.

Many clients ask me: "How many days does an employee need to work for me before my company becomes the chargeable employer for Illinois Unemployment Insurance purposes?"

There is a simple unemployment insurance rule that Illinois employers should be aware of: A company will usually not be "charged" for an ex-employee's unemployment insurance benefits if that ex-employee did not work for the company for at least 30 working days.

This is an extremely simple rule that employers should keep in mind because, if used properly, it is a wonderful way for a company to help keep its unemployment insurance rate down.

Below are some examples to provide guidance on how the Illinois Department of Employment Security (IDES) calculates the 30 working days: 
  1. The individual works a shift which begins at 10:00 p.m. on Monday and ends at 7:00 a.m. on Tuesday. While this individual performs services for this employer on two calendar days, for the purpose of determining whether the 30 day requirement has been met, the individual's shift counts as only one day of service (Monday).
  2. The individual begins his shift at Noon but becomes ill fifteen minutes later. Since the individual performed services for the employer for fifteen minutes, one day is counted toward meeting the 30-day requirement.
  3. The individual is scheduled to work on a certain day but fails to report for work because he is ill. Even if the employer provides paid sick leave to the individual for that day, it will not be counted toward the 30-day requirement.
  4.  Upon the permanent layoff of an individual, the employer pays that individual for any unused, accrued vacation time that the individual is due and grants him severance pay in the amount of one day's pay for each year of continuous service. These payments are not included for the purpose of determining whether this employer has met the 30-day requirement.
  5. The individual works a four-day work week. That is, instead of working eight hours per day, five days per week, he works ten hours per day, four days per week. Even if the individual's ten-hour shift extends over two calendar days, each shift still counts as only one day, and this individual will have worked only four days in a normal work week.
Overtime work (or working additional shifts) is not included in determining whether the 30-day requirement has been met unless there is at least 6 hours between the beginning of the overtime work (or the additional shift) and the end of the prior shift and the overtime work (or additional shift) does not occur on a day which will otherwise be included in meeting the 30-day requirement. Examples:
  1. The individual's normal shift ends at 3:00 a.m., and he is asked to work the next shift which begins at 4:00 a.m. Even if he works both shifts, since there is not at least 6 hours between the shifts, only one day will be counted toward meeting the 30-day requirement.
  2. The individual's shift ends at 3:00 a.m. on Saturday, and he is asked to return to work for an additional overtime shift from 9:00 a.m. until 2:00 p.m. He must then return to work at 7:00 p.m. to work his regular shift. This overtime work does not count as an additional day toward meeting the 30-day requirement because his regular shift begins that same day and would already be included in meeting the 30-day requirement.
  3. The individual's normal shift begins at 3:00 p.m. and ends at 11:00 p.m. However, he is required to work four hours of overtime every day so that he does not complete his shift until 3:00 a.m. This shift still counts as only one day toward the 30-day requirement.
 NOTE: An employer may also become the chargeable employer after less than 30 days if it was the single employer that paid wages to the individual permitting the individual to requalify for benefits after a previous disqualification under Section 601 (voluntary leaving), 602 (misconduct), or 603 (refusal of work). To requalify, the individual must earn an amount equal to or in excess of his current Weekly Benefit Amount in each of four calendar weeks.

Questions? Please contact WS Shareholder and Senior Attorney Nancy Joerg at (630) 377-1554, or najoerg@wesselssherman.com.

Seventh Circuit Backs Walmart Firing of Anti-Gay Religious Employee

October 2011
By: Nancy E. Joerg, Esq.

On March 31, 2011, the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals [in an unpublished Opinion (No. 10-2242)] ruled in favor of defendant Walmart and found no evidence of religious discrimination.

By way of background, in September 2005, Tanisha Matthews (an overnight stocker at Walmart for nine years) became involved in a heated discussion about God and homosexuality with a lesbian co-worker, named Amy, during a break. When Walmart officials later investigated the incident, they learned that Ms. Matthews screamed at Amy that God does not accept gays, that gays should not "be on earth," and that they will "go to hell" because they are not "right in the head."

After the three-month investigation of the incident by Walmart, Walmart fired Ms. Matthews for violating Walmart's Discrimination and Harassment Prevention policy. This policy clearly prohibits Walmart employees from harassment based on an individual's status, including sexual orientation.

Upon being fired, Tanisha Matthews sued Walmart under the civil rights laws, arguing that Walmart fired her for stating her sincere religious belief that gays will go to hell, which she maintained is central to her Apostolic-Christian faith. The trial court granted summary judgment to Walmart, finding no evidence for the religious discrimination claim.

Next, Tanisha Matthews brought her religious discrimination case to the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals. However, Ms. Matthews did no better on appeal.

The Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court's decision, noting the following:
"Walmart fired [Matthews] because she violated the company policy when she harassed a coworker, not because of her beliefs, and employers need not relieve workers from complying with neutral workplace rules as a religious accommodation if it would create an undue hardship. In this case, such an accommodation could place Walmart on the 'razor's edge' of liability by exposing it to claims of permitting workplace harassment."

Clearly, Tanisha Matthews believed that she had a religious duty to scream anti-gay epithets at her Walmart coworkers. Tanisha Matthews believed and unsuccessfully argued that Walmart must permit her to admonish gays at work to accommodate her religion.

The bottom line in this case is that the Seventh Circuit decided that Ms. Matthews' right to exercise her religious freedom at work did not permit her to harass gay people. Walmart fired Ms. Matthews "because she violated company policy when she harassed a co-worker, not because of her beliefs," the Seventh Circuit ruled. Even though Ms. Matthews' anti-gay harassment was religious-inspired, Walmart did not violate Ms. Matthews' civil rights when it fired her.

This case stands for the common sense principle that the Civil Rights Act does not protect religious-based bigotry in the workplace. Walmart fired Tanisha Matthews because she violated company policy when she harassed a co-worker, not because of her religious beliefs.

Anti-gay remarks by employees professing religious beliefs are not part of religious accommodation in the workplace.

Congress adopted Title VII of the Civil Rights Act in 1964. Title VII makes it unlawful for an employer to discriminate against an applicant/employee with respect to hiring, firing, promotion, or any other terms or conditions of employment based on that employee's race, color, religion, sex or national origin.

In addition to this prohibition against religious discrimination, employers are affirmatively required by state and federal law to reasonably accommodate employees' religious observances and practices unless such accommodation causes undue hardship to the employer. Courts have ruled that a proposed accommodation of a religious belief is an undue hardship if it imposes more than a de minimis cost on the employer. The EEOC has stated that an employer can show undue hardship if accommodating an employee's religious practices requires more than ordinary administrative costs, diminishes efficiency in other jobs, infringes on other employees' job rights or benefits, impairs workplace safety, causes coworkers to carry the accommodated employee's share of potentially hazardous or burdensome work, or if the proposed accommodation conflicts with another law or regulation.

In this case brought by Tanisha Matthews, Walmart's anti-harassment policies trumped her religious speech. This Seventh Circuit decision is a message to all employees that if their employer wishes to bar anti-gay sentiments expressed in the workplace; the employer can establish policies and fire violators-even if the anti-gay rhetoric is based on sincerely held religious beliefs.

An interesting side note: Tanisha Matthews also relied on a decision by the Illinois Department of Employment Security, finding that the misconduct that led to her termination was not severe enough to bar her from receiving unemployment benefits. However, the Seventh Circuit found that the unemployment insurance decision was irrelevant because it was based on a different definition of misconduct used only for employment-benefits decisions.

Questions? Call Attorney Nancy E. Joerg of Wessels Sherman's St. Charles, Illinois office: 630-377-1554 or email her at najoerg@wesselssherman.com. 

Which Illinois Unemployment Insurance Contribution Rate Do I Use, The Employee Leasing Company's or the Client Company's?

June 2011
By: Nancy E. Joerg, Esq. & Chad A. Staul, Esq.

While it is true that an Illinois Employee Leasing Company (also known as a "PEO") allows employers to bundle and better manage payroll, workers' compensation, human resource compliance and employee benefits, those looking to also use a PEO to get a better unemployment insurance contribution rate (contribution rate) should be aware that this is far from a guarantee.

Some employers are under the misconception that if they lease employees from a PEO (thereby becoming a "client company"), they can automatically use the PEO's more favorable contribution rate. While this may be true in some instances, it is not always the case.

The Illinois Department of Employment Security (IDES) follows very stringent statutory requirements that must be met in order to determine if a PEO's client company can use the better contribution rate. See 820 ILCS 405/206.1. The following illustrates these requirements by breaking them down into three straightforward steps:

STEP 1: In order to use the PEO's contribution rate, the leasing contract with the client company must provide:
  • That the PEO pays the individual directly from its own accounts;
  • That the PEO, either exclusively or with the client company, retains the right to direct and control the individual in the performance of the services; and
  • That the PEO, either exclusively or with the client company, retains the right to hire and terminate the individual.
STEP 2: If the leasing contract meets the Step 1 requirements, then the PEO must file an IDES Report containing:
  • The name of the client company;
  • A general description of the client company's business and locations;
  • The client company's unemployment insurance account number (if any);
  • The effective date of the employee leasing company's contract with the client company; and
  • The report must be accompanied by either a power of attorney to represent the client company or a certification by an officer or employee of the employee leasing company that the information in the report is true and correct to the best of his or her knowledge. See 56 Ill. Adm. Code 2732.306.
STEP 3: After checking the leasing contract for compliance with Step 1 and filing the report required by Step 2, each of the PEO's client companies must pass muster under a specific mathematical formula provided by 820 ILCS 405/206.1(C).

In its simplest terms, the issue comes down to who the IDES recognizes as the employer of a leased employee for purposes of unemployment insurance. If the PEO and the client company meet all of the statutory requirements outlined in Steps 1-3 above, then the IDES will likely recognize the PEO as the employer; allowing the PEO to report wages on behalf of the client company under the PEO's contribution rate. However, a client company that does not meet the statutory requirements is not relieved from reporting wages for the leased employees and must continue to do so under its existing rate.

For example, let's say a PEO leases employees to three different client companies, A, B and C. Further, let's assume that the PEO leasing contract meets Step 1 above and that the PEO has sent the IDES the required report for all three client companies required by Step 2 above. Upon review, the IDES determines that only client companies A and B meet the statutory mathematical requirements in Step 3. In practical application, the PEO will be allowed to do all the wage reporting for client companies A and B under its single contribution rate, but client company C will have to continue reporting separately under its different less favorable rate. Note that this has no impact on any other aspect of the employee leasing contract between the PEO and client company C.

Because of the complexities and detailed involvement the IDES has placed on whose contribution rate controls in an employee leasing situation, employers that use or are thinking about using a leasing company need someone who can wade through the minutiae and give them a straight answer. The consequence for improper wage reporting based on confusion or missteps in the above process may lead to the IDES imposing interest and penalties on both the client company and the PEO.

Questions? Call Attorney Nancy E. Joerg of Wessels Sherman's St. Charles, Illinois office: 630-377-1554 or email her at najoerg@wesselssherman.com.