Friday, September 25, 2015

Warning for Illinois Accountants: Significant Change in IDES Audit Policy!

October 2013

Starting in early 2013, the Illinois Department of Employment Security (IDES) "increased the pain" on Illinois businesses using independent contractors. The IDES audit division modified their audit policy guidelines to be much more likely to result in multi-year audits.

Now, IDES auditors will audit an Illinois company for a second year if the first year being audited results in an assessment of only $2,000 or more.

In other words, if an Illinois company is audited by the IDES and the auditor finds that (for that initial audit year) the company has made enough "mistakes" to result in money owed to the IDES in the amount of $2,000 or more, then the IDES auditor will proceed to audit that company for another year. There used to be a much more forgiving $5,000 threshold, so now there is a much greater danger of multi-year audits.

In my opinion as an attorney who has handled many IDES audits over twenty-four years, this new audit policy is misguided in many ways. It is very damaging financially to small Illinois businesses that use independent contractors (if those independent contractors are found to be employees by the IDES auditor under the brutal test for independent contractor status). Keep in mind that the interest rate that the IDES inflicts on these harsh assessments is 24% per year (2% per month).

Accountants and others advising their Illinois clients should take immediate action when they find out that one of their clients is going to be audited by the Illinois Department of Employment Security. The best advice to clients and their advisors is to first "say nothing whatsoever" to the IDES auditor until experienced legal counsel is obtained (and the Company can understand its legal position/vulnerability and then can effectively plan its defense strategy).

The independent contractor test used by the IDES--Section 212 (A), (B), and (C)--must be thoroughly understood and discussed with the client before any conversation takes place between the company/accountant and the IDES auditor. Seemingly innocuous questions by the IDES auditor such as "what does the company do" and "what does the independent contractor do" are frighteningly important in terms of an accurate legal analysis under Section 212 (A), (B), and (C).

Much harm or much good can be done right at the beginning of an IDES audit, so immediate legal advice should be sought. A strategy for defending independent contractor status should be developed right at the beginning of the audit process, to avoid a multi-year IDES audit and to reduce potential reclassification liability.

If any readers of this e-mail would like a free copy of Section 212 (A), (B), and (C) of the Illinois Unemployment Insurance Act and its Regulations to better understand the severity of the IDES test for independent contractor status, please contact Legal Assistant Tammy Nelson at 630-377-1554 or via email at tanelson@wesselssherman.com.

Questions about lowering your clients' risk in the use of independent contractors or how best to handle an IDES audit? Call Attorney Nancy E. Joerg of Wessels Sherman's St. Charles, Illinois office: 630-377-1554 or email her at najoerg@wesselssherman.com.

Wednesday, September 16, 2015

Significant Change Coming In U.S. Department of Labor Audits Involving Independent Contractors

July 2013

The 2014 budget for the U.S. Department of Labor was released on April 10, 2013, and it has troubling overtones for employers. By evaluating this very telling budget information, it becomes clear that the U.S. Department of Labor is unfortunately going to change the way it organizes its enforcement activities aimed at worker classification (i.e., whether certain workers are independent contractors or employees).

MORE INVESTIGATIONS BASED ON INDUSTRY: According to this 2014 budget information, the U.S. Department of Labor will increase the percentage of investigations that it does based upon industry rather than complaints.
 
In the past, the U.S. Department of Labor has based its independent contractor investigations largely on complaints made by disgruntled workers. Now, the U.S. Department of Labor will look at companies in industries with a high prevalence of worker misclassification.
 
CERTAIN INDUSTRIES MORE LIKELY TO HAVE WORKER MIS­CLASSIFICA­TION: The U.S. Department of Labor’s 2014 budget information notes that certain industries are more likely to have worker misclassification (some of the industries named in this regard are construction, janitorial, home health care, child care, transportation, warehousing, meat and poultry processing, personnel service, etc).
 
The bottom line here is that a company using independent contractors may not have any reported complaints from its workers, but that company may still be targeted by the U.S. Department of Labor for an audit.
COORDINATION WITH VARIOUS STATES: The U.S. Department of Labor continues to threaten that it is going to coordinate its efforts in investigating independent contractor status with various states. 
 
The Obama administration has been vocal about the fact that it wants to increase its investigation and enforcement of those businesses that use independent contractors and also increase its coordination with other federal and state agencies.
 
COMPANIES SHOULD HAVE INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR RELATION­SHIPS CAREFULLY REVIEWED BY A KNOWLEDGEABLE PROFESSIONAL: Any company that uses independent contractors should realize that the climate throughout the United States is much more aggressive in terms of state and federal investigation. Therefore, those companies should be sure to have their websites, independent contractor agreements and documentation, and overall independent contractor relationships carefully reviewed by a knowledgeable professional.
 
For consultations on limiting your liability in the use of independent contractors, contact Attorney Nancy E. Joerg, who enjoys a nationwide reputation in assisting companies who use Independent Contractors of all types.  Nancy Joerg can be reached at Wessels Sherman’s St. Charles, Illinois office: 630-377-1554 or email her at najoerg@wesselssherman.com.

Friday, July 17, 2015

Review of Scalia/Ginsburg (The Opera)


July, 2015
By Nancy E. Joerg, Esq.

On Saturday, July 11, 2015, I attended the world premiere of the one act comic opera Scalia/Ginsburg and thought it would be fun to share this experience.

On Friday, July 10, 2015, I flew to Dulles airport in Washington D.C., rented a car, and found myself out in the extremely beautiful and very rural area of Virginia where the Castleton Music Festival is located. The Castleton Festival takes place each summer on a very picturesque 650 acre farm, surrounded by gorgeous rolling hills, the Shenandoah National Park, and the Blue Ridge Mountains.

The opera, Scalia/Ginsburg, is based on the opinions and dissents of two very vocal Supreme Court Justices, Antonin Scalia and Ruth Bader Ginsburg. Justice Scalia is the outspoken and fiery “originalist” conscience of the Supreme Court, and Justice Ginsburg is a passionate advocate for equal rights, especially gender equality. Yet they are buddies. They often travel together, attend operas together, ring in the New Year together, and very much appreciate each other as colleagues and friends.

Recent high profile Supreme Court cases, such as the marriage equality Obergefell decision, have brought the sharp differences in judicial philosophy among the Supreme Court Justices into especially keen public awareness.

THEME OF THE OPERA: The theme of Scalia/Ginsburg is that, even though Scalia and Ginsburg are sharply divided on treatment of many constitutional issues, these two Justices of the Supreme Court are united in their deep respect for the institution of the Supreme Court. There is a beautiful duet towards the end of the opera entitled “We are Different, We are One.” In that duet, Scalia (in a role sung by a feisty black-robed tenor) and Ginsburg (played by a charming black-robed soprano) sing about the tremendous devotion that the Justices of the Supreme Court share for the court. They sing together:

“Separate strands unite in friction
To protect our country’s core.
This, the strength of our nation,
Thus is our Court’s design:
We are kindred,
We are nine.”

GINSBURG AND WANG WERE IN ATTENDANCE: Prior to the opera’s world premiere that evening, Ruth Bader Ginsburg gave a fascinating one hour talk about the law as it appears in the plots of many operas. Castleton opera singers sang and acted out Ginsburg’s humorous examples of the intertwining law and the opera.

Later that evening, Ruth Bader Ginsburg and her son James Ginsburg (founder of Cedille Records in Chicago) attended the world premiere of Wang’s opera and sat two rows in front of me. Also, the composer (and librettist) of the opera, Derrick Wang, was present. The Castleton audience (containing, among others, many members of the Washington, D.C. legal community) warmly applauded both Ginsburg and Wang when they were introduced from the stage. Justice Scalia did not attend the premiere of Scalia/Ginsburg as he was in Rome.

COMPOSER DERRICK WANG: The composer, Derrick Wang, graduated from Harvard with a degree in music and then went on to Yale for a Masters in music. He then went to the University of Maryland Carey School of Law. While he was studying constitutional law there, he was struck by the operatic quality of Justice Scalia’s very dramatic and forceful opinions and dissents. Derrick Wang could hear a “rage aria” in his mind as he studied Scalia’s angry dissenting words. Derrick Wang also realized that the opinions and dissents of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg were very strong in a completely different way. Wang could hear a soprano singing her carefully crafted words.

CONTENT OF THE OPERA: Scalia/Ginsburg takes place in a chamber in the Supreme Court. There is just one set for the entire one act opera. There are only three singers: Scalia (a tenor), Ginsburg (a soprano), and a Commentator (bass-baritone) who is in the role of a celestial bureaucrat, sent to put Justice Scalia through three trials (to see if Scalia is guilty of “excessive dissenting”). The Commentator sings:

“I am the Commentator!
I come from a powerful administration,
And I am here to conduct an investigation
Into why you have managed to be so unrelenting
In spending so much of the past eight-and-twenty years in substantial, and
possibly excessive, dissenting.”

Both Scalia and Ginsburg are presented by Wang in a sympathetic light. It is not the intent of the opera to approve of one to the disadvantage of the other. On the contrary. Wang does a fine job of explaining the firmly held positions of both Scalia and Ginsburg.

The opera was charming, clever and amusing. Derrick Wang loaded Scalia/Ginsburg with musical jokes and clever references from Scalia’s and Ginsburg’s legal opinions and public remarks. Classic Scalia phrases such as “argle bargle” and “sheer applesauce” were inserted into the libretto at key points, to the delight and applause of the enthusiastic audience.

Scalia sang in utter frustration:

“The Justices are blind!
How can they possibly spout this—?
The Constitution says absolutely nothing about this,
This right that they’ve enshrined—
When did the document sprout this?
The Framers wrote and signed
Words that endured without this;
The Constitution says absolutely nothing about this!”

Scalia sings to his good friend and colleague, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, about her errors in interpreting the Constitution to include expanding rights:

“Oh, Ruth, can you read? You’re aware of the text,
Yet so proudly you’ve failed to derive its true meaning,
And never were so few
Rights made so numerous—
It’s almost humorous
What you construe!”

The music contains fragments from such classical music sources as Carmen, La Traviata, La Bohème, the Star Spangled Banner, and Mozart. This is an opera which will appeal to lawyers, Supreme Court watchers and opera lovers.

Ginsburg actually appears on the set of the opera by “crashing through a glass ceiling.” She is there to help Scalia pass his three trials as set by the Commentator.

Scalia sings a wonderful aria where he recalls his father as a man of great moral character who built stone stairs and was an immigrant who revered America and the fundamental and traditional values. Scalia sings:

“And so he taught me what he knew:
Follow the rules
Down to the letter:
Stay good and right and true,
For brains and brawn will sell without fail,
But character is never for sale.
His virtues,
His values,
They built stairs,
Lending me support
As I reached this Court,
Where I have judged and learned.”

The message of the opera is that the Supreme Court has justices who respect and care about each other at a deep and sincere level, even though they often have vastly different jurisprudential theories.

GINSBURG’S LATE HUSBAND: At the end of the opera was a nod to Justice Ginsburg’s late husband Marty Ginsburg who was a tax attorney. Marty had taught himself (early in their marriage) to cook elaborate French cuisine after he discovered his wife had no interest in cooking. (Currently there is a book sold in the Supreme Court gift shop entitled Chef Supreme which is a collection of Marty Ginsburg’s recipes.)

I highly recommend that anyone interested in the Supreme Court, the Constitution, and the human drama surrounding these vital Supreme Court decisions attend a showing of Scalia/Ginsburg if it is given again in the future (I hope it will be; I would go again).

Derrick Wang’s score for the opera includes many direct quotations from the judicial writings of both Scalia and Ginsburg. Printed versions of the enjoyable and witty libretto for the opera have detailed footnotes citing not just the source of the text but the musical allusions. For those readers who are interested in the libretto, it can be found online in The Columbia Journal of Law & The Arts at: http://lawandarts.org/articles/scaliaginsburg-a-gentle-parody-of-operatic-proportions/.

Questions or comments? Contact attorney Nancy Joerg, Managing Shareholder of the St. Charles office of Wessels Sherman at (630) 377-1554 or via email at najoerg@wesselssherman.com

Friday, March 13, 2015

The Difficult Job of Proving Misconduct to the Illinois Department of Employment Security (IDES) When a Truck Driver is Terminated for Poor Performance

March 2015
By Nancy E. Joerg, Esq.



As one would expect, sometimes a trucking company finds it best to terminate a truck driver for poor performance. This poor performance may involve very serious accidents or negligence (such as cross-dropping no lead gasoline into a premium tank, thereby contaminating that product). Sometimes, instead of properly loading thousands of gallons of no-lead and thousands of gallons of mid-grade, the driver carelessly loads thousands of gallons of no-lead and thousands of gallons of premium.

While there is of course usually no problem in terminating a driver who has had many accidents which cost the company time, money and damage to their reputation, our trucking clients are often surprised when they don’t win with the Illinois Department of Employment Security (IDES) - if the terminated truck driver files for unemployment insurance benefits with the IDES.

What many trucking clients don’t realize is that the IDES WILL give unemployment insurance benefits to drivers (even when they have had many serious accidents in the course of their employment) if the trucking company cannot successfully prove that these accidents were willful and deliberate on the part of the employee truck driver.

IDES DEFINITION OF MISCONDUCT: The IDES works under a strict legal definition of misconduct which requires that the trucking company prove that the incident was intentional, willful and deliberate. Mere negligence and terrible driving or a series of significant mistakes or accidents do not qualify as misconduct under the IDES definition.

Under Section 602A of the Illinois Unemployment Insurance Act, the definition of misconduct is:  “the deliberate and willful violation of a reasonable rule or policy of the employing unit, governing the individual’s behavior in performance of his work, provided such violation has harmed the employing unit or other employees or has been repeated by the individual despite a warning or other explicit instruction from the employing unit.” 

Section 602A requires deliberate and willful behavior and that behavior must have caused harm to the trucking company.  (These elements need to be proven by the trucking company in order for unemployment insurance benefits to be blocked.)

TIPS FOR TERMINATION LETTER: When you terminate a truck driver for a series of incidents in the course of their truck driving, indicate in the termination letter what reasonable rule or policy the truck driver intentionally failed to follow. This is a way to win with the IDES, by emphasizing the deliberate and willful nature of the driver’s behavior. For example, if the driver failed to double check the gasoline in a manner in which he was instructed by the trucking company, then that might be a winning strategy to block his claim for unemployment insurance benefits.

PROTESTING THE DRIVER’S CLAIM FOR UNEMPLOYMENT: Keep this in mind the next time you protest a truck driver’s claim for unemployment insurance benefits with the IDES…your goal is to prove to the IDES that the truck driver’s behavior was willful, deliberate and intentional. Merely pointing out what a bad driver that individual was is NOT a winning strategy. Accidents and negligence are (sadly) not enough.

For assistance with IDES audits, hearings, and independent contractor agreements (or for consultations on limiting your liability in the use of independent contractors), contact Attorney Nancy E. Joerg, who enjoys a nationwide reputation in working with companies who use Independent Contractors of all types. Nancy Joerg can be reached at Wessels Sherman's St. Charles, Illinois office: 630-377-1554 or email her at najoerg@wesselssherman.com.

Friday, February 27, 2015

U.S. District Court Upholds OSHA Subpoena in Grain Enguflment Case

July 2011
By: Nancy E. Joerg, Esq.

This OSHA case arises from a particularly tragic and heart-wrenching fact pattern. On July 28, 2010, two teenagers died in a grain bin tragedy. The United States Department of Labor Occupational Safety & Health Administration (OSHA) investigated the deaths which occurred as a result of grain engulfment at the company's grain elevator in Mt. Carroll, Illinois. The two teenagers "drowned" in a sea of grain in the grain bin. OSHA eventually hit the company with numerous violations and fines (which the company is fighting).

OSHA SUBPOENA: As part of the hard fought legal battle between OSHA and the grain bin company, OSHA issued a subpoena demanding inspection reports and documents prepared by the grain bin company's workers' compensation carrier. The workers' compensation carrier argued in court that it should not have to provide OSHA with the safety inspection records. The carrier lost this legal struggle in May of 2011.

WORKERS' COMPENSATION INSURANCE COMPANY ARGUED UNSUCCESSFULLY AGAINST THE SUBPOENA: The workers' compensation insurance company argued unsuccessfully that the subpoena from OSHA would actually discourage businesses from permitting workers' compensation insurance carriers to conduct safety inspections. The insurance carrier told the court that if the inspection reports can be used against a business during later litigation or OSHA enforcement proceedings, such safety inspections would be curtailed. However, on May 2, 2011, the court did not agree with the insurance carrier and therefore ordered that the safety inspection records be given to OSHA. ( Hilda L. Solis v. Grinnell Mutual Reinsurance Co.)

COURT'S DECISION: Judge Philip G. Reinhard of the U.S. District Court of Northern Illinois ruled on May 2, 2011 that OSHA has jurisdiction to investigate the workplace fatalities; and further, has the authority to require the production of relevant evidence and the ability to issue a subpoena to obtain that evidence. The requested documents, which included copies of site safety inspections, applications for insurance coverage for the site, and correspondence between the workers' compensation insurer and the grain bin company concerning the site, were found by Judge Reinhard to "reasonably relate to the investigation of the incident and the question of OSHA jurisdiction."

GRAIN BIN SAFETY: Grain bin safety has become an important focus for OSHA. OSHA's Region V, which includes Illinois, Ohio and Wisconsin, initiated a Grain Safety Local Emphasis Program in August 2010, and has since conducted 61 inspections and cited grain operators/facilities for 163 violations. The 163 violations cover hazards associated with grain engulfment, machine guarding, electricity, falls, employee training, combustible dust and lockout/tagout of energy sources on potentially dangerous equipment. Grain bins are extremely hazardous work environments and OSHA is trying to decrease danger where possible in these bins.

OSHA has great legal powers to investigate workplace safety matters. Courts generally support OSHA's mission. Companies should expect that all safety inspection records are likely to be obtained by OSHA when it investigates.

Questions about OSHA or any related matters? Please contact WS Shareholder and Senior Attorney Nancy E. Joerg at 630-377-1554 or najoerg@wesselssherman.com.

Employer Alert: Keep Track of 30 Working Days for Illinois Unemployment Insurances Purposes

March 2010
By: Nancy E. Joerg, Esq.

Many clients ask me: "How many days does an employee need to work for me before my company becomes the chargeable employer for Illinois Unemployment Insurance purposes?"

There is a simple unemployment insurance rule that Illinois employers should be aware of: A company will usually not be "charged" for an ex-employee's unemployment insurance benefits if that ex-employee did not work for the company for at least 30 working days.

This is an extremely simple rule that employers should keep in mind because, if used properly, it is a wonderful way for a company to help keep its unemployment insurance rate down.

Below are some examples to provide guidance on how the Illinois Department of Employment Security (IDES) calculates the 30 working days: 
  1. The individual works a shift which begins at 10:00 p.m. on Monday and ends at 7:00 a.m. on Tuesday. While this individual performs services for this employer on two calendar days, for the purpose of determining whether the 30 day requirement has been met, the individual's shift counts as only one day of service (Monday).
  2. The individual begins his shift at Noon but becomes ill fifteen minutes later. Since the individual performed services for the employer for fifteen minutes, one day is counted toward meeting the 30-day requirement.
  3. The individual is scheduled to work on a certain day but fails to report for work because he is ill. Even if the employer provides paid sick leave to the individual for that day, it will not be counted toward the 30-day requirement.
  4.  Upon the permanent layoff of an individual, the employer pays that individual for any unused, accrued vacation time that the individual is due and grants him severance pay in the amount of one day's pay for each year of continuous service. These payments are not included for the purpose of determining whether this employer has met the 30-day requirement.
  5. The individual works a four-day work week. That is, instead of working eight hours per day, five days per week, he works ten hours per day, four days per week. Even if the individual's ten-hour shift extends over two calendar days, each shift still counts as only one day, and this individual will have worked only four days in a normal work week.
Overtime work (or working additional shifts) is not included in determining whether the 30-day requirement has been met unless there is at least 6 hours between the beginning of the overtime work (or the additional shift) and the end of the prior shift and the overtime work (or additional shift) does not occur on a day which will otherwise be included in meeting the 30-day requirement. Examples:
  1. The individual's normal shift ends at 3:00 a.m., and he is asked to work the next shift which begins at 4:00 a.m. Even if he works both shifts, since there is not at least 6 hours between the shifts, only one day will be counted toward meeting the 30-day requirement.
  2. The individual's shift ends at 3:00 a.m. on Saturday, and he is asked to return to work for an additional overtime shift from 9:00 a.m. until 2:00 p.m. He must then return to work at 7:00 p.m. to work his regular shift. This overtime work does not count as an additional day toward meeting the 30-day requirement because his regular shift begins that same day and would already be included in meeting the 30-day requirement.
  3. The individual's normal shift begins at 3:00 p.m. and ends at 11:00 p.m. However, he is required to work four hours of overtime every day so that he does not complete his shift until 3:00 a.m. This shift still counts as only one day toward the 30-day requirement.
 NOTE: An employer may also become the chargeable employer after less than 30 days if it was the single employer that paid wages to the individual permitting the individual to requalify for benefits after a previous disqualification under Section 601 (voluntary leaving), 602 (misconduct), or 603 (refusal of work). To requalify, the individual must earn an amount equal to or in excess of his current Weekly Benefit Amount in each of four calendar weeks.

Questions? Please contact WS Shareholder and Senior Attorney Nancy Joerg at (630) 377-1554, or najoerg@wesselssherman.com.